Ask five pastry chefs which vanilla is best and you will get five confident answers. Put the same five vanillas in front of them, unlabelled, in the same warm milk, and the answers become far more interesting. Preferences shift, assumptions about origin fall away, and the qualities that actually matter in your kitchen become visible. A structured tasting is the cheapest, most persuasive tool in vanilla buying, and most kitchens and food companies never run one.
To compare vanillas fairly, taste them side by side, blind, in the same neutral base. Prepare each sample at the same dose by weight, infused the same way in warm milk or cream, plus a plain sugar syrup or custard if you want to test performance. Code the samples with numbers, taste from mildest to strongest, and score each on agreed attributes such as intensity, sweetness, woodiness, floral notes and off-notes. Use the results alongside cost per dose to choose.
I run tastings for kitchens and product teams, and the format below works for a chef choosing a house vanilla, a buyer comparing samples from three suppliers, or a team training new staff. It takes about an hour and needs nothing more than a few pans, small cups and a scoring sheet.
What You Can Learn From a Tasting
Compare samples of the same grade from different suppliers, blind, before you commit to a trial order.
See how Indonesian, Madagascar and other origins differ in your actual application.
Find out whether a cheaper extraction grade gives the same result in your base as gourmet beans.
Give staff a shared vocabulary for describing vanilla and recognising faults.
Taste a new delivery against a retained reference from a lot you were happy with.
Show buyers or clients why a particular vanilla is worth its price.
Preparing the Samples
The rule is simple: everything must be the same except the vanilla. Same base, same dose by weight, same infusion time and temperature, same cups, same serving temperature. Any difference in preparation becomes a difference in flavour that you will wrongly attribute to the beans.
Infuse
For each vanilla, weigh the same quantity of split beans, for example 2 g per 250 ml of whole milk or a milk and cream mix. Heat gently, infuse, then refrigerate overnight with the beans in.
Strain and code
Strain each infusion and pour into identical jugs coded with random three-digit numbers. Keep the key separate.
Warm
Warm each sample to the same temperature, around body temperature, where aroma reads clearly.
Serve
Serve small cups in a different order for each taster, with water and plain crackers between samples.
Beans differ in size and moisture. Dosing by weight gives a fairer comparison. If you want to compare value, note the price per gram of each so you can work out cost per dose afterwards.
Choosing the Bases
| Base | What it shows | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Warm milk infusion | Overall aroma and flavour in fat; the most revealing single test | Use whole milk or a milk and cream mix |
| Sugar syrup | Aroma without fat; harsh or off-notes stand out | Useful for spotting faults |
| Plain custard or crème anglaise | Performance in a real pastry application | Make one batch of base and divide it |
| Whipped cream | Cold, fatty application, like ice cream or mousse | Shows which vanillas fade in cold |
| Smelling split beans | Aroma of the beans themselves | Do this first, before tasting, on a fresh split |
A Vocabulary for Vanilla
Tasting is easier when everyone uses the same words. These are the attributes I ask tasters to score. They are not technical terms, and you can adapt them, but agreeing them before the tasting makes the results comparable.
Origins tend to differ in characteristic ways. Indonesian Planifolia is often described as deeper and woodier, Madagascar Bourbon as sweet and creamy, and Tahitian as floral and fruity. But individual lots vary widely, and curing matters as much as origin. A blind tasting is valuable precisely because it tests the lot in front of you, not the reputation of its country.
Scoring and Deciding
Tasting summary
Example layout · warm milk infusion · 6 tasters · blind
Only reveal the key after scoring. In this illustrative result, the cheapest lot had a smoky off-note that most tasters noticed, the Madagascar sample was the sweetest and creamiest, and the Indonesian sample was the strongest and woodiest at a lower cost per dose. Which one wins depends on the application: the Madagascar for a delicate cream, the Indonesian for ice cream or chocolate.
Common Tasting Mistakes
Tasting with labels showing
Knowing the origin or price shapes perception. Code the samples.
Different doses
Comparing a strong dose of one vanilla with a weak dose of another tests the dose, not the bean.
Too many samples
After five or six, palates tire. Run two sessions if you have more.
Serving too cold
Cold hides aroma. Taste warm first, then in a cold application if relevant.
Only one base
A vanilla that shines in milk may fade in a cold mousse. Test in your real application.
Running a Tasting for a Team
Tastings for staff training work best when they are short, regular and practical. Start with two vanillas that are clearly different, such as a woody Indonesian bean and a floral Tahitian, so everyone can hear the difference. Add a deliberately faulty sample, such as a smoky or over-dry bean, so staff learn to recognise problems. Over several sessions, move to finer comparisons, such as two Indonesian lots of the same grade, until the team can spot a change in a new delivery on their own.
- Two clearly different vanillas to start.
- One deliberately faulty sample to learn from.
- The same base and dose for every sample.
- A printed vocabulary sheet so everyone uses the same words.
- Discussion after scoring, not before.
- A record of results to repeat the session later.
Using Tastings With Customers
A short tasting can also sell. A café, a specialty shop or a supplier presenting to a food manufacturer can put two or three vanillas in front of a customer and let them taste the difference for themselves. This works best when it is honest: label the samples after tasting, explain the origin and grade, and connect the difference to the price. Customers who have tasted why a vanilla costs more are far more willing to pay for it than customers who have only been told.
Recording Results Over Time
Keep a simple log: date, samples tasted, base, dose, scores and the lot numbers revealed after the tasting. Over months, the log shows which suppliers deliver consistently, how lots change with the seasons, and which vanillas your team and customers prefer. It also gives you something concrete to show a supplier when a lot falls short.
Tasting for Extract Makers
Extract makers can taste in the same way, with one adjustment: compare finished extracts rather than infusions. Make small trial extracts from each bean at the same ratio by weight, in the same alcohol and water mix, and age them for the same time before tasting, diluted in warm milk or sugar water. It takes longer, because extraction needs weeks, but it shows how each bean performs in the actual product. It also reveals differences in yield and colour that an infusion cannot. Record the bean’s moisture and vanillin alongside the tasting scores, because the best-tasting bean is not always the best value per litre of extract.
Include one sample twice under different codes. If tasters score the two very differently, the panel needs more practice before its results can be trusted for big decisions.
Finally, remember that tasting is one input, not the whole decision. A vanilla that wins a tasting still has to meet your specification for moisture, vanillin and defects, arrive on time with clean documents, and come from a supplier you trust to repeat it. Use the tasting to choose between options that already pass those tests, and you will rarely regret the result.
Turning a Tasting Into a Standard
Once you have chosen a vanilla, keep a sealed reference sample from the chosen lot and use the same tasting to check every new delivery against it. A five-minute comparison in warm milk will tell you whether the new lot is the same, better or worse long before it reaches a customer. Record the result with the lot number. Over a year, those notes become the most useful quality record a kitchen can keep.
The Pastry Chef’s Indonesian Vanilla Pairing Guide describes how Indonesian origins taste and perform in different applications, with pairing suggestions, so you know what to listen for in a tasting. Indonesian Vanilla Grading explains how grade affects what you taste, and when a lower grade will do the same job in your base.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I compare vanilla beans fairly?
ATaste them blind, side by side, in the same neutral base, at the same dose by weight, infused the same way and served at the same temperature.
What is the best base for tasting vanilla?
AA warm milk or milk and cream infusion is the most revealing single test. Sugar syrup shows off-notes clearly, and a custard or whipped cream shows performance in real applications.
How much vanilla should I use in a tasting?
AUse the same weight for every sample, for example 2 g of split beans per 250 ml of milk. Weighing is fairer than counting beans.
What attributes should I score in a vanilla tasting?
AIntensity, sweet or creamy character, woody or earthy notes, floral or fruity notes, length, and any off-notes such as smoky, musty or medicinal.
How does Indonesian vanilla taste compared with Madagascar?
AIndonesian Planifolia is often described as deeper and woodier, Madagascar Bourbon as sweeter and creamier. Individual lots vary, which is why blind tasting is useful.
How many vanillas can I taste at once?
AFive or six is usually the limit before palates tire. Run separate sessions for more.
How do I check a new vanilla lot against my standard?
AKeep a sealed reference sample from the approved lot and taste the new lot against it in warm milk, blind, recording the result with the lot number.
Further reading: ISO 5565 — vanilla specification and test methods