← The Vanilla Journal
Sourcing GuideNovember 10, 2026

The One-Page Vanilla Grading Card That Ends the “Grade A” Argument

Every exporter’s best vanilla is “Grade A.” That is the problem in a sentence. No international standard defines the letter; the seller draws the line wherever it flatters the lot, and the same pod can change grade simply by moving to a warehouse that grades more generously. Meanwhile the three numbers that genuinely decide what a bean is worth — moisture, length and vanillin — get quoted on whichever basis makes the lot look best, or left off the conversation entirely. If you are comparing offers that all say “Grade A,” you are not comparing grades. You are comparing marketing, and paying real money on the result.

Quick Answer

No international standard defines “Grade A” vanilla — it is trade shorthand set by each seller. What actually decides value is three numbers: moisture (how much of the weight is water), length (which tracks grade bands), and vanillin (the flavour compound, reported on a dry or as-is basis). The Indonesian SNI 01-0010-2002 and ISO 5565 standards define real quality bands, but you can also judge a carton yourself with four tests that need only a scale, a ruler and your senses.

3
numbers that decide value: moisture, length and vanillin
4carton tests you can run with no instruments
0international standards that define the letter “Grade A”

This guide replaces the grade letter with something you can measure. It explains where the three numbers come from, what the Indonesian and ISO standards actually say (and where trade practice takes over), and how to check a carton at your own table so that “Grade A” stops being a word you take on trust.

Part 1

Why the Grade Letter Tells You So Little

Grading systems for vanilla are commercial, not statutory, in most of the trade. An exporter might run A/B/C bands, or I/II/III, or “gourmet / extraction / cuts,” and no two draw the lines in quite the same place. One house’s Grade A is another’s second band. Because the letter is assigned by the seller, it carries their incentives, not yours. The only way to make a grade meaningful is to attach numbers to it — and the numbers that matter are moisture, length and vanillin. Those numbers have real, knowable ranges. A well-cured Indonesian Grade A (gourmet) bean typically runs 25–35 percent moisture, around 2.0 percent vanillin, and 15–20+ cm in length, coming in near 250–300 beans per kilogram because the extra moisture adds weight. A Grade B (extraction) bean is drier at roughly 15–25 percent moisture, shorter at about 10–15 cm, similar or slightly lower on vanillin, and runs higher — nearer 300–350 beans per kilogram. Grade C covers cuts, splits and short pieces below about 15 percent moisture. Notice that vanillin barely separates A from B: it is appearance, moisture and length that do, which is why a seller can call a short, plain, dry bean ‘Grade A’ and not quite be lying.

“

“Grade A” is a label, not a measurement. The letters are trade shorthand, and each exporter draws the lines in a different place.

The sentence to remember
Part 2

The Three Numbers, One at a Time

Everything that decides a bean’s value reduces, in practice, to three measurements. Understand what each one does and you can read any offer, whatever letter is on it.

01Moisture

How much of the weight is water. Higher moisture means a suppler, more fragrant bean — and more weight you pay vanilla prices for. Two labs can disagree on the same lot depending on method, so moisture always needs a method behind it.

02Length

Longer beans command higher grades and prices, and length bands are the backbone of most grading systems. It is also the easiest number to verify yourself — a ruler settles it.

03Vanillin

The compound that carries flavour, reported either on a dry basis (water removed) or as received (water included). The two differ by a third or more, so a vanillin figure without its basis is unusable.

The quiet money is in the moisture–vanillin interaction. A lot can look strong on a dry-basis vanillin figure while carrying so much water that, as received, you are buying far less vanilla than the number implies. Read moisture and vanillin together, on the same basis, or the headline will mislead you every time.

The dry-basis conversion is where lots quietly change rank

A lot at 1.8 percent vanillin and 20 percent moisture can carry more vanillin per usable kilogram than a lot at 2.0 percent vanillin and 35 percent moisture, because a third of the second lot is water. Convert both to the same basis before you decide which is “stronger.” The weaker-looking lot is often the better buy.

Part 3

What the Standards Actually Say

Two real standards sit behind the trade letters, and knowing what they cover — and do not — lets you cite something firmer than an exporter’s house grade. The Indonesian national standard SNI 01-0010-2002 sets general requirements and a quality table for vanilla; the international ISO 5565 (in two parts) defines specification and test methods. Both give you defined moisture ceilings and quality bands you can write into a contract — a far stronger footing than “Grade A.” The clearest proof that the letter alone means little: ask several reputable sources what moisture a Grade A bean carries and you get materially different answers — 25–30 percent, 30–35 percent, 25–35 percent, and, for Madagascar gourmet sub-grades, 30–38 percent. All are defensible, because no single body sets the line. The statutory SNI top grade itself permits moisture into the upper thirties, so even top grade does not pin the number down.

SNI 01-0010-2002

The Indonesian national standard: general requirements and a quality table. It defines bands and permits a wide moisture range at the top grade, which is exactly why “top grade” alone does not pin down moisture.

ISO 5565, parts 1 and 2

The international standard: specification and the test methods behind the numbers. Useful when a buyer and seller in different countries need a neutral reference both recognise.

The commercial bands

A/B/C, I/II/III, gourmet/extraction — the names sellers actually quote. They map loosely onto the standards, but the mapping is the seller’s, so treat it as a claim to verify, not a fact.

What they do not do

Neither standard reproduces as a free text, and neither makes “Grade A” mean one thing. They give you bands and methods; you still have to specify which band, at what moisture, in your own terms.

The practical upshot: cite the standard’s band and its numbers, not the seller’s letter. “Moisture not exceeding [X] percent by the SNI method” is enforceable; “Grade A” is an opinion. If a contract clause will ever turn on a figure, quote the purchased standard text, not a summary of it.

Part 4

Four Tests You Can Run at the Table

You do not need a laboratory to catch most of what matters. A kitchen scale, a steel rule and your own senses will tell you whether a carton resembles what you were sold. Run these the same way every time, and record the results so two lots are judged on identical terms.

  • The knot — a supple, well-cured bean bends and can be tied in a loose knot without snapping; a brittle one is over-dry or old.
  • Count and weigh — count the beans in a known weight to get beans per kilogram, an objective proxy for size and grade that is hard to fake.
  • The cut — slice a bean and look at the interior: seed density, oiliness and colour the exterior hides.
  • The smell, twice — once on opening the carton, and again after the beans have rested in a sealed jar for a day, to catch fermentation or off-notes the surface did not show.
Frost is not mould — and confusing them is expensive

White crystals on a bean’s surface are often vanillin that has migrated out and recrystallised — “givre,” a sign of a high-vanillin bean, not spoilage. True mould is fuzzy, patchy and smells wrong. Rejecting a frosted lot as mouldy throws away your best beans; accepting a mouldy lot as frosted brings a problem into your warehouse. The cut and the jar test tell them apart.

Part 5

Turning the Carton Into a Contract

The last step is to turn what you measured into something the supplier signs. A specification that names a moisture range, a length band, a vanillin minimum on a stated basis, and the method for each is enforceable; a grade letter is not. Keep a retained sample — a sealed portion you and the supplier agree on — so a later dispute can be tested against agreed material rather than two memories. This is how the grading card earns its keep: not as a reference you read once, but as the source of the numbers you put in your terms.

Part 6

The Six Things You’ll Find in a Carton

A carton of cured vanilla is never uniform, and knowing what the normal range of contents looks like keeps you from over-reacting to the harmless and under-reacting to the costly. Alongside the sound, supple, well-coloured beans you paid for, expect to find some variation in length and colour, the occasional split, a little surface frost on the better lots, and — in a poorer lot — the things that should concern you: true mould, an off or fermented smell, excessive splits, foreign matter, and beans so dry they snap. The skill is telling the acceptable variation from the genuine defect, because a carton with none of the former does not exist, and a carton with much of the latter is a problem you want to catch at the bench, not in production.

This is also where sampling discipline matters. Judge the carton from a representative handful drawn across it, not from the beans sitting on top, which may have been arranged. Count and weigh from several points, cut beans from different parts of the carton, and let the overall picture — not the single best or single worst bean — set your view of the lot. One beautiful bean proves the lot can contain a beautiful bean; it proves nothing about the rest.

Indonesian Vanilla Grading sets all of this out — the three numbers and where they come from, SNI 01-0010-2002 and ISO 5565 in plain English, the commercial bands and what each is likely to mean in numbers, the four carton tests with a short defect atlas, and a one-page grading card you can print and keep on the bench. It turns “they said Grade A” into a judgement you can make and defend yourself.

Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Is “Grade A” vanilla an official standard?

No. No international standard defines Grade A — it is trade shorthand assigned by each seller, so one exporter’s Grade A can be another’s second band. The figures that actually decide value are moisture, length and vanillin, which is why you should specify those numbers rather than rely on the letter.

What three numbers decide the value of vanilla?

Moisture (how much of the weight is water), length (which drives grade bands and price), and vanillin (the flavour compound). Read moisture and vanillin together on the same basis, because a high dry-basis vanillin figure on a very wet lot can mean less usable vanilla than a lower figure on a drier lot.

What is the difference between dry-basis and as-received vanillin?

Dry basis reports vanillin with the bean’s water removed, giving a higher number than the as-received basis that includes moisture — often a difference of a third or more. A vanillin figure with no stated basis cannot be compared between lots, so always confirm which basis a supplier is quoting.

What standards define Indonesian vanilla quality?

The Indonesian national standard SNI 01-0010-2002 sets general requirements and a quality table, and ISO 5565 (parts 1 and 2) defines specification and test methods. They give defined bands and methods you can cite in a contract, but neither makes “Grade A” mean a single thing, so you still specify which band and what moisture.

Can I grade vanilla myself without lab equipment?

Yes, for most of what matters. A kitchen scale, a steel rule and your senses let you run four tests — the knot test for suppleness, counting and weighing for beans per kilogram, the cut test for interior condition, and smelling on opening and after a day in a sealed jar — which together reveal far more than a grade letter.

Are the white crystals on vanilla beans mould?

Usually not. White crystals on the surface are often vanillin that has migrated out and recrystallised, called givre, which signals a high-vanillin bean rather than spoilage. True mould is fuzzy and patchy and smells wrong; the cut and jar tests distinguish the two, and confusing them is a costly mistake either way.

How do I make a vanilla grade enforceable in a contract?

Replace the grade letter with numbers: a moisture range, a length band, and a vanillin minimum on a stated basis, each with its test method, ideally citing the SNI or ISO band. Keep a sealed retained sample both sides agree on, so a later dispute is tested against agreed material instead of competing recollections.

Further reading: ISO 5565 — vanilla specification, Badan Standardisasi Nasional (SNI)


Want to grade by numbers, not a letter?

We quote against moisture, length and vanillin on a stated basis, with lot-specific certificates. Send us an enquiry.

Discuss Sourcing
© 2026 Vanilla Roots · vanillaroots.comAdmin